
It leaves me a bit disconcerted to ponder how much peanut butter Matthew packs away in a given week. It’s just about a food group of its own in our family. While Megan will rave about the flavor of capers in her Pork Piccata or at least try my latest kitchen concoction, Matthew isn’t exactly an adventurous eater.
Nearly every morning since he was about two, Matthew has started his day with a bowl of “hot-water oatmeal” (we tried to break from the packets of instant and go with a home-cooked bowl of porridge with no success -- this other story of our parental nutrition ineptitude will have to wait for another day), a toasted frozen waffle and often a slice of toast, liberally coated with jelly, and yes, peanut butter.

Should the night’s dinner menu consist of anything beyond stir-fried beef, pizza or spaghetti, we get some pouting, and maybe a bit of a battle of wills. Often we will compromise. After at least a few bites trying the night’s entrĂ©e, Matthew can have a PBJ sandwich.
Becky has tried to include turkey or salami sandwiches in his school lunch. They come home untouched. It’s to be peanut butter and jelly, or nothing, thank you.
While we had a brief dalliance with Jif and one time an organic brand from the health food store, we are a Peter Pan peanut butter family. Now the man from Neverland -- or at least his corporate overseer -- has let us down. I already was worried about the transfats or other health-hindering nasties contained in the jars of peanut butter. Now we have to worry about
salmonella?
After hearing of the
recall, we rushed home to check the serial number on the lid of the jar residing in our home. Sure enough, we had one of the “2111” prefixes on the lid indicating potential contamination.
Matthew was sick earlier in the week and missed a day from school because he was throwing up. Could it have been contaminated peanut butter? ConAgra (with a corporate name like that, you can understand why they prefer to hide behind a friendlier-sounding brand of Peter Pan) has let us down. Peter Pan Peanut Butter is off the shelves at the store and off the shelves of our cupboard as well.
When we did a Google search earlier in the week for updates about the recall, we found ConAgra touting the glorious history of the Peter Pan product, but no readily clicked-to details about its potential to sicken children. They since have included a
link on the Peter Pan page to provide updates about how to avoid illness and procure a refund. It certainly was not as to-the-point as this headline on the Web site of the Food and Drug Administration:
FDA Warns Consumers Not to Eat Certain Jars of Peter Pan Peanut Butter and Great Value Peanut Butter
We will seek a refund for our latest jar. But the money we receive likely will go to a different company.
It's over Peter Pan. Fly away. You are about as welcome as Captain Hook would be in our home.